RobotRisk Autonomous Systems Incident & Risk Register
RobotRisk / Tesla / 2025-08-01

Federal jury finds Tesla 33% liable in fatal 2019 Key Largo Autopilot crash

S4 · 08/01
2025 · Tesla · Key Largo, FL, USA

Record

CompanyTesla
Categoryav trucking
Typeregulatory
Date08/01
2025
Time of daynot documented
LocationKey Largo, FL, USA
SeverityS4 (serious injury, total loss, or grounding)
Scale1 fatality; jury verdict against Tesla
Confidencemedium
VerificationYes - adversarially checked against the cited source
SourceWikipedia (citing New York Times, Aug 2025 trial coverage)

What happened

In the first Autopilot wrongful-death case to reach a federal jury verdict, jurors found Tesla 33 percent responsible for a 2019 crash in Key Largo, Florida in which a Model S with Autopilot engaged ran a stop sign and killed a pedestrian, awarding substantial damages.

Tesla record context

Entries by year and severity

10212016 S5: 11162018 S5: 11182019 S5: 11192022 S3: 12022 S5: 12222023 S3: 12023 S4: 12023 S5: 24232024 S2: 22024 S3: 22024 S4: 12024 S5: 49242025 S1: 12025 S2: 152025 S3: 22025 S4: 22025 S5: 121252026 S2: 162026 S3: 42026 S5: 12126
S1S2S3S4S5

By incident type

By severity

Tesla vs av trucking alternatives

av trucking context

av trucking: entries by year

3496982016 S5: 11162018 S5: 11182019 S5: 11192021 S1: 11212022 S2: 12022 S3: 32022 S5: 15222023 S1: 12023 S2: 12023 S3: 32023 S4: 42023 S5: 211232024 S1: 42024 S2: 92024 S3: 72024 S4: 22024 S5: 426242025 S1: 62025 S2: 5362025 S3: 132025 S4: 42025 S5: 4563252026 S1: 22026 S2: 6582026 S3: 312026 S4: 42026 S5: 369826
S1S2S3S4S5

av trucking: failure modes

av trucking: most entries

regulatory context

regulatory: by category

regulatory: by year

regulatory: severity profile

Comparable regulatory events in av trucking

SevDateCompanyEvent
S32026-09-03TeslaNHTSA opens Audit Query AQ26002 into Tesla Cybercab certification
S32026-05AvrideNHTSA opens probe into Avride after Texas self-driving crashes
S32026-04Baidu Apollo GoChina suspends new AV permits after Baidu's mass outage
S32026-01-23WaymoWaymo vehicle investigated after striking pedestrian and passing stopped school bus
S32025-12WaymoWaymo Vehicles Reportedly Passed Stopped School Buses 19 Times, Prompting NHTSA Probe
S32025-10-24TeslaNHTSA probes Tesla 'Mad Max' FSD mode over reckless driving behavior
S32025-10-17WaymoNHTSA investigates Waymo robotaxis for failing to stop for school buses
S52024-10-18TeslaNHTSA investigates Tesla Full Self-Driving after crashes including a fatality

Other Tesla entries

Also from Critical Systems Analysis: CSA - functional safety engineering · Company directory · FSTalent - functional safety jobs